Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your Recipe Rating




46 Comments

  1. Hi Dassana, hope you are doing good. Love your recipes a lot.

    Wanted to know if I can shape these cookies? Or only circular is possible with this recipe?

    1. Thank you Arjita. Yes, I am good.

      The dough is soft, tender and light. So it may be tricky to shape them using cookie cutters or cutting a rolled cookie dough with a knife. These cutout cookies may fall apart while handling.

      I would suggest to keep the dough in the fridge for about 1 to 2 hours. It will be easier to give different shapes to a chilled cookie dough.

  2. Hello, thank you for this recipe. I am quite fond of ginger cookies, so I want to try making some on my own this time.

    I am a complete newbie to baking, so please excuse me for asking these questions that might seem basic knowledge.

    I am going to use maida and brown sugar for my recipe, so how should the proportions be tweaked for water and other ingredients?

    Should the butter be at room temperature or just put out from fridge when about to mix ingredients?

    Also, should sugar be powdered before mixing or can I use it as is from the packet?

    Sorry for asking too many questions.

    1. No problem. When using maida, you will have to add less water. You can always water later when working on the dough. Add water bit by bit, so that the cookie dough does not become sticky.

      Butter needs to be soft, not melted, but soft and spreadable. It can be cold. If after removing from the fridge, the butter is hard, let it soften a bit at room temperature.

      Brown sugar need not be powdered. Since it is has very fine granules, it will dissolve in the butter when creamed together.

      I hope these answers help.

      1. Thank you so much for kindly answering my queries. I finally got around to make the cookies today. They turned out good!!

        There was one hiccup initially, maybe its because of the chilly weather, as I was using brown sugar, butter and sugar water were not mixing and stayed separate even after beating for 30 mins with an electric beater.

        I got fed up and put my mixing bowl in the microwave for 30 sec at its highest power. The mixture came out with the exact consistency as you showed in the pictures above. I beat it for about 10 sec for good measure before proceeding with the next steps. It was smooth sailing thereafter.

        These cookies have an airy texture compared to the ones I bought from bakery, so I might be emptying my jar sooner than I thought 😉

        I have one question though, the flavor of the spices is not so prominent, its just about there. I had used fresh grated ginger and used store bought powdered spices for the rest of them.

        Do you think the flavour would have been much more enhanced if I used freshly ground ones instead?

        In case I want to make them again with the store bought spice powders, by how much should I increase the proportions so that I get strong flavor?

        The cookies that I generally buy from my local bakery have a very strong flavor, you can feel them bursting in your mouth from the first bite, akin to biryani (I am comparing about how strong the flavor is, not the taste, haha). I would like to replicate that flavor if possible.

        Sorry, my post got too lengthy without my realizing it, but I am very grateful for your recipe.5 stars

        1. No problem. Writing a bit late as I was travelling. Ginger powder will give a more strong flavor than fresh ginger. Dry ground spices have more potent and intense flavor than fresh ones. You could also opt to grind the cloves, cinnamon freshly in a grinder.

          2 teaspoons of dry ginger powder is perfect for this recipe. But if you want a more ginger flavor, add ½ to 1 teaspoon more. You could also increase the clove, cinnamon, nutmeg powder to ½ teaspoon each.

          Thank you and welcome.

  3. Ginger bread cookies came out nicely using this recipe. I have just one cooking related app in my phone and it’s Veg Recipes. Thank you for all the recipes.

  4. Hi,
    I want to make these cookies with brown sugar and make it less sweet, how should I tweak this recipe??
    I love your work, I have tried many recipes and all have turned out really good! Thank you so much for your well written, well explained instructions.

    Preeti

    1. thanks a lot preeti. for less sweet cookies, you will need to add about 1/3 cup sugar. this will make the cookies less sweet. for just about sweet, you can add 1/2 cup of brown sugar. also some more water or milk needs to be added to bind the dough. beat the butter with the brown sugar first and then proceed with the recipe.

  5. Turned out lovely. This was my third attempt at cookies. First two times with other’s recipes which were disasters. I used whole-wheat and increased water by a tbsp. My 3 year old is running around the house eating these as I type this comment. We don’t give him store brought cookies so he’s on 7th heaven 🙂 Thank you for your recipes. You should see my kid’s happy face 🙂5 stars

  6. Ur recipes are amazing…hats off to u and thank you…have been sharing ur link with all and also bookmarked it on my cell

  7. Thanks for the amazing recepie. It came out really well. It is crispy on the outside and soft from the inside. I added candied ginger instead of grated ginger. Whenever I am exhausted from work or need to relax, I try one of your recepies. From the basic dal to exotic lasagna I refer your recepies. Thanks so much.

  8. Hello. I have tried many of your recepies successfully. Few years back I tried to make cookies but the centre part of the cookie didn”t bake well and the side parts got over-cooked and hardened. Since then I have been reluctant to try cookies. Could you tell me some tips to make the cookies well.
    Also should the consistency of cookie dough be same as that of chapati dough?5 stars

    1. shruti, the consistency is not like a chapati dough. after reading your comment, it looks like that the dough was kneaded. cookie doughs are just gently mixed. they are not kneaded like the way we knead chapati dough. otherwise the cookies become very hard.

  9. Hi,
    Happy new year to you.These cookies tasted like mini gingerbread cakes..Lovely soft texture,but is there anyway I cud get them a bit crisper?

    1. pleased to know this ashwini 🙂 glad you liked the gingerbread cookies. the recipe will need some tweaking to make them crisp. you could add a few teaspoons more of the butter to get a crisp texture.

  10. Hi …ur recipes r good…being an ayurvedic doctor I always search for healthy recipes..I have tried few of ur recipes…came out well thank u…I need to ask u is it possible to bake cake without using baking soda or powder…. N will u pl share ur mail I’d. so that if I have any doubts will mail n ask

    1. thanks and welcome shubha. nice to know. it is possible to make cookies without baking soda or baking powder, but eggless cakes are difficult. i use aluminum free baking powder. its available on amazon.in. you can send your doubts at vegrecipesofindia(AT)gmail(DOT)com

    1. yes you can. but do remember that whole wheat flour absorbs more liquids than maida or all purpose flour. so you need to add more liquids while binding the cookie mixture. also seive the whole wheat flour with baking soda or baking powder, for any recipe that you follow.

  11. Great recipe, as always Dasana. I want to know which brand of unsalted butter do you use? Also is it possible to use homemade white makkan instead? If yes, should I use the same weight as butter? Thanks

    1. thanks swati. at times i make unsalted butter at home and at times i buy from the parsi dairy. yes you can use homemade makhan. i also use it at times. yes, same weight as that of butter.

      1. Thanks Dasana for the reply. Will try with homemade makkan. Also would be great if you could post a recipe of how to make butter at home.

  12. I have followed all the step carefully. The crispness is missing in the cookies. Can you pls tell me what may went wrong.

  13. Looks yummy! I was wondering if I could use date syrup instead of kakvi? These will be perfect for a Xmas tea 🙂 Thanks for sharing the recipe!

    1. dates syrup will work. but dates syrup will be thick than kakvi. so i suggest adding more hot water towards the end instead of 1/4 cup. depending on the consistency of the dates syrup, you can add 1/3 to 1/2 cup hot water.