Mayonnaise Sandwich

Step by StepJump to Recipe

This Mayonnaise Sandwich is a tasty and easy-to-prepare vegetarian sandwich made with veggie stuffing and my homemade vegan and Eggless Mayonnaise. This light and mildly flavored sandwich is perfect for a summer picnic or to serve as a finger snack during parties or get-together. Make this quick recipe with my step-by-step photos and video.

mayonnaise sandwich topped with grated carrots and cheese on a square white plate

About This Recipe

These mayonnaise sandwiches are light and refreshing. The boiled potatoes blend perfectly with the mayo to produce a nice creamy spread. The added veggies give a crunch and nutritional boost to the sandwich and the seasonings are mild, but perfectly paired with the flavor of the mayo.

There are many ways a veg mayonnaise sandwich can be made. Here I give you the basic method for preparing the mayo filling and constructing the sandwich as well as tips on ingredients and seasonings. Once you have the basic idea, feel free to adapt the recipe to your preference.

It is also easy to prepare the mayo stuffing and have it ready to add to bread for a quick lunch or snack throughout the week.

This vegetarian recipe can easily be made vegan by using dairy-free mayo and vegan butter.

Ingredients you need

Besides a good quality Eggless Mayonnaise, the other key ingredient that makes this sandwich work are the soft-boiled potato cubes. The texture of the boiled potatoes works perfectly with the mayonnaise.

This recipe includes grated carrots and chopped bell pepper (capsicum), however feel free to add different or additional veggies, including cabbage, steamed corn kernels and steamed green peas.

In the video, steamed corn kernels are added while in the step-wise photos, I have not added them.

Just be sure that the proportion of veggies to mayo gives you a nice consistency so that it spreads well on the bread.

Any bread can be used, but for a healthy version include whole wheat bread or rye bread or multi grain bread.

Step-by-Step Guide

How to make Mayonnaise Sandwich

1. In a mixing bowl take ⅓ cup grated carrots and ¼ cup finely chopped bell pepper (capsicum). You can also add veggies like some steamed corn kernels, steamed green peas and shredded cabbage at this step.

grated carrots and chopped bell pepper in a bowl

2. Add one medium-sized potato, which has been boiled, peeled and chopped. The addition of potatoes are optional but I do recommend adding them as they make the sandwiches filling and hearty. They also give a good texture and taste.

chopped boiled potatoes added

3. Add ⅓ cup Veg Mayonnaise. You can use your preferred brand of eggless or vegan mayonnaise. Instead of mayo you can use greek yogurt or thick sour cream.

mayonnaise added

4. Add ¼ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper and ¼ teaspoon ground mustard (mustard powder).

If you do not have ground mustard, then simply crush ⅛ teaspoon mustard seeds in a mortar pestle. Or you can add ¼ teaspoon dijon mustard.

seasonings added

5. Mix very well. For a slightly sweet taste, you can also add ¼ to ½ teaspoon sugar. But do keep in mind that if your mayo has a more sweet taste then don’t add sugar.

If you want, you can also add some red chili flakes or some dried herbs like oregano, thyme, basil.

mayo stuffing mixed very well

6. Spread butter on the bread slices.

butter spread on bread

7. Now spread the stuffing on the bread slices.

veg mayo stuffing spread on bread

8. Place on top the remaining buttered slices and slice the sandwich in rectangles or triangles or small squares. At this point, if you’d like, you can toast or grill these sandwiches.

mayonnaise sandwich ready and sliced

9. While serving the veg mayonnaise sandwiches you can garnish them with some grated carrots and grated cheddar cheese. Accompany them with some banana chips, potato chips or potato wedges.

They make for a good after-school snack for kids as well as a hearty evening snack.

veg mayonnaise sandwich topped with grated carrots and cheese on a square white plate

Serving Suggestions

These mayo sandwiches also make for a perfect light breakfast, lunch or snack. As they taste great cold, these sandwiches also work great to pack in a picnic or as a packed lunch. Easily multiply the recipe and serve them as a finger snack during parties. 

You can serve veg mayo sandwiches plain or accompany them with some potato chips or french fries or potato wedges.

Variations 

For a vegan version, simply use a vegan mayonnaise and plant-based butter or just skip spreading the butter on the bread. Or else, if you are just looking to avoid eggs, use an eggless mayonnaise, or else make your own homemade eggless mayonnaise.

This version is for a cold, non-toasted sandwich, but you can easily toast or grill these mayonnaise sandwiches if you prefer a warm sandwich with a crispy crust.

Tips

Expert Tips

  • Always include the boiled potato cubes as the soft texture of the potatoes goes very well in a veg mayo sandwich.
  • Steamed corn kernels taste good in mayonnaise stuffing. You can steam or boil the corn at home or you can also use canned corn. In place of corn you can use steamed green peas.
  • You can use any bread, like whole-wheat bread, or brown bread or white bread or rye bread or multi-grain bread. To make it healthy, avoid using white bread.
  • For a bolder flavor and a bit of spice, add some red chili flakes or some dried herbs like oregano, thyme and basil into the mayonnaise sandwich stuffing.

FAQs

How long can these mayo sandwich stay good?

These veg mayo sandwiches stay good for about 1 to 2 hours when refrigerated as they are made with a homemade eggless and vegan cashew mayo. But for the best taste and flavor I recommend to serve them as soon as they are made. If you have made these sandwiches with egg based mayo or milk-based mayo, then eat them as soon as you prepare them.

Can these be prepared in advance for a party?

Yes, you can prepare them an hour earlier and refrigerate, if you have used a vegan plant based mayo. Later serve these as a cold sandwiches.

How to avoid soggy sandwich?

This recipe does not yield a soggy sandwich as there are no juicy or watery vegetables added. Just do not add tomatoes, cucumber and lettuce in the sandwich to avoid sogginess.

What can be subbed for mayo?

You could use greek yogurt or thick sour cream in place of mayonnaise.

More Popular Sandwich Recipes

If you made this recipe, please be sure to rate it in the recipe card below. Sign Up for my email newsletter or you can follow me on Instagram, Facebook, Youtube, Pinterest or Twitter for more vegetarian inspirations.

mayonnaise sandwich topped with grated carrots and cheese on a square white plate

Mayonnaise Sandwich

This is a tasty and easy to prepare mayonnaise sandwich made with mix veggies, mayonnaise and spices. These sandwiches make for a hearty snack that can be made quickly.
4.92 from 12 votes
Prep Time 15 mins
Total Time 15 mins
Cuisine American, World
Course Snacks
Diet Vegetarian
Difficulty Level Easy
Servings 4 Mayo Sandwiches
Units

Ingredients

Main ingredients

  • cup grated carrots
  • ¼ cup finely chopped bell pepper (capsicum)
  • 1 medium potato – boiled and chopped
  • cup Veg Mayonnaise – eggless or vegan, add as required
  • ¼ teaspoon black pepper powder or add as required
  • ¼ teaspoon ground mustard (mustard powder)
  • ¼ teaspoon sugar – optional
  • 8 to 10 bread slices – whole wheat, brown, white or multigrain bread
  • Butter as required

For garnish

  • 1 to 2 tablespoon grated carrots – optional
  • 1 tablespoon grated cheddar cheese – optional

Instructions
 

Preparation

  • In a mixing bowl take the grated carrots, finely chopped bell pepper. You can also add some steamed corn kernels, steamed green peas and shredded cabbage.
  • Add one medium sized potato, which has been boiled, peeled and chopped.
  • Add mayonnaise, black pepper powder and ground mustard (mustard powder).
  • If you do not have mustard powder, then just crush ⅛ teaspoon mustard seeds in a mortar-pestle or you can add ¼ teaspoon dijon mustard.
  • Mix very well. You can also add ¼ to ½ teaspoon sugar for a slight sweet taste. If your mayo has a more sweet taste then don't add sugar. You can also add some red chili flakes or some dried herbs like oregano, thyme, basil.

Making mayo sandwich

  • Spread butter on the bread slices. 
  • Now spread veg mayonnaise stuffing on the bread slices.
  • Place on top the remaining buttered slices and slice the mayo sandwiches in rectangles or triangles or small squares. You can even toast or grill these sandwiches.
  • While serving mayonnaise sandwich, you can garnish with some grated carrots and grated cheddar cheese.
  • They can be served for breakfast, brunch or as an after school snack.

Video

Notes

  • The recipe can be scaled to make a big batch for parties.
  • Use homemade mayonnaise or your preferred brand of vegetarian or vegan mayo.
  • Don’t use watery veggies like cucumber, lettuce, beets if you plan to serve the sandwich after some minutes or an hour. 
  • You can add your choice of herbs and spices. Both dried herbs as well as fresh herbs work in the recipe.
  • For a healthier option use whole meal bread, multi grain bread or rye bread.
  • For a vegan mayo sandwich omit the butter or use plant based butter. Also use vegan mayonnaise.
  • Note that the approximate nutrition info is for one sandwich made with whole wheat bread and non-fat mayo.

Nutrition Info (Approximate values)

Nutrition Facts
Mayonnaise Sandwich
Amount Per Serving
Calories 264 Calories from Fat 81
% Daily Value*
Fat 9g14%
Saturated Fat 5g31%
Trans Fat 1g
Polyunsaturated Fat 1g
Monounsaturated Fat 3g
Cholesterol 19mg6%
Sodium 403mg18%
Potassium 441mg13%
Carbohydrates 38g13%
Fiber 6g25%
Sugar 7g8%
Protein 9g18%
Vitamin A 2643IU53%
Vitamin B1 (Thiamine) 1mg67%
Vitamin B2 (Riboflavin) 1mg59%
Vitamin B3 (Niacin) 3mg15%
Vitamin B6 1mg50%
Vitamin B12 1µg17%
Vitamin C 19mg23%
Vitamin D 1µg7%
Vitamin E 1mg7%
Vitamin K 13µg12%
Calcium 91mg9%
Vitamin B9 (Folate) 41µg10%
Iron 2mg11%
Magnesium 63mg16%
Phosphorus 165mg17%
Zinc 1mg7%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

Like what you see?

Stay up to date with new recipes and ideas.

This Mayonnaise Sandwich recipe post from the archives (first published in January 2017) has been republished and updated on 17 June 2021.

Share This Recipe:

PinWhatsAppPrintShares996

Meet Dassana

Welcome to Dassana's Veg Recipes. I share vegetarian recipes from India & around the World. Having been cooking for decades and with a professional background in cooking & baking, I help you to make your cooking journey easier with my tried and tested recipes showcased with step by step photos & plenty of tips & suggestions.

Get My Secrets to Great Indian Food
Sign up for my FREE Beginners Guide to Delicious Indian Cooking

Comments are closed.

21 Comments

    1. these mayo sandwiches stay good for about an hour as they are made with a vegan cashew mayo.

  1. Hi…can these be prepared in advance for a party? In such case, what is the procedure to be followed so that they don’t turn soggy?5 stars

    1. you can spread some butter generously on the bread and then add the mayo stuffing. this way the sandwiches won’t become soggy.

See More Comments