Tomato Ketchup Recipe (Indian Tomato Sauce)

Tasty, vibrant, homemade Tomato ketchup or Tomato sauce bound to have you coming back for more. This tomato ketchup is loaded with fresh ingredients like tomatoes, garlic and ginger making the flavors rich and delicious. It is also low-fat, vegan and gluten-free. Serve tomato ketchup with your favorite side or snacks.

About Tomato Ketchup Recipe

Before I begin to write about this recipe, let me tell you that the names tomato ketchup and tomato sauce are used interchangeably in India. Whereas tomato sauce is known as a base used to make tomato pasta in the West.

An easy-to-follow homemade DIY tomato ketchup recipe perfect for vegans. I had purchased an Indian tomato ketchup brand that tasted like syrup, was pasty and off.

It made me wonder what had gone wrong in this tomato ketchup? It tasted less of the tomatoes and more like a sugar syrup. That’s when I decided to make a homemade tomato ketchup with fresh ingredients.

The week after I bought 3 kilograms of organic tomatoes and used 2.5 kilograms to make homemade tomato sauce. This yields 1 liter of tomato ketchup.

There was a huge difference between the taste, flavor, and aroma of the homemade tomato ketchup and the shop-bought ketchup. The homemade ketchup sauce is full of tomato goodness, there is no pastiness and no excess sugar.

This vegan tomato sauce recipe has been adapted from my cooking school notes. This is quite a different recipe and includes ginger, garlic, and dry red chilies.

The red chilies give a gentle touch of heat to the sauce. The hotness and smokiness from the red chilies are strong when the sauce is freshly simmered but as the sauce ages and mellows, the hotness and smokiness become very subtle.

If you taste the sauce alone you might get the heat but if you have the sauce with a snack or any accompaniment you won’t feel it.

Raisins are added to this sauce for sweetness. As a result, you don’t need to add as much sugar and you get to avoid the overly sweet shop-bought ketchup taste. Use organic unrefined cane sugar or raw sugar for the best taste.

The preservative sodium benzoate is added to the sauce so that it can be stored for a longer period of time. Store the sauce in a sterilized canning jar. The sauce can be kept for about 6 months but it’s so delicious that it will finish before then!

You can serve tomato sauce with varieties of snacks like fritters, Aloo Tikki, Veg Cutlet, French Fries etc.

You can make the ketchup without the preservative too, but make sure the jar is sterilized properly. You can also halve or reduce the recipe.

How to make Tomato Ketchup

Prep and Cook Tomatoes

1. Rinse the tomatoes in water and then drain the water. Use fresh ripe tomatoes.

2. Chop them roughly. Remove the skin and parts which are blemished or spotted.

3. Now in a large casserole, pot or 4 to 5 liter pressure cooker, add the chopped tomatoes.

You can also use Instant pot to cook the ingredients.

4. Then add the following ingredients:

• 3 pieces of about 3-inch chopped ginger
• 15 to 16 medium-sized chopped garlic cloves
• ½ cup golden raisins
• 5 to 7 halved dry red chilies. Remove the seeds from the chilies. Use any mild to medium-hot red chilies.

5. Pour in ½ cup apple cider vinegar or white vinegar.

6. Add 6 to 7 tablespoons of raw sugar. You can also add maple syrup or white sugar.

7. I kept the cooker on low flame. Stir very well and simmer without a lid. In the below photo you see the result after 9 minutes. You don’t need to add any water.

8. Simmer and cook the tomatoes until they are softened. The tomatoes will soften after 25 to 27 minutes.

The timing will vary depending on what you use to cook the tomatoes and the intensity of the flame.

9. When the mixture is slightly hot or warm use an immersion blender to make a nice smooth puree. Alternatively, you can make the puree in an electric blender.

Tip: Make sure you puree the mixture very well. If the puree is coarse then it will be difficult to strain the pulp.

10. Strain the puree with a spoon. Do not use a fine strainer as the tomato puree needs to be able to pass through.

11. Important step. You have to really keep on mashing the pulp with the spoon so that all the puree is drained. The pulp mixture should be somewhat dry and not moist.

Straining the puree can be a time-consuming task. The bigger the strainer the quicker the process will be.

12. The pan should have all of the smooth, pulp free tomato goodness and is ready to be made into ketchup.

Make Tomato Sauce

13. Now place the pan containing the strained tomato pulp on the stovetop and leave it to simmer for 5 to 6 minutes. Check the taste and add more sugar if necessary. You can also add sugar towards the end once the tomato sauce has thickened.

14. Continue to simmer the sauce and stir at intervals.

15. After 20 minutes the sauce should have thickened even more.

16. The tomato sauce should spend at least 40 minutes on the stovetop in total. Continue to stir the sauce from time to time.

Feel free to thicken it more if you want. Once you are happy with the consistency leave the sauce to cool. It will become thicker after cooling too.

17. To check if the sauce is done spread the tomato sauce on a plate. There should be no water droplets on the sides. You can see a slight separation happening. This is alright.

But if you want a thick ketchup sauce like the readymade ones, then you have to cook it for longer until the tomato ketchup coats a spoon and remains like that.

Do check the taste of the sauce once the cooking is complete. Add more sugar if needed.

Store Tomato Ketchup

18. Add the tomato ketchup to a sterilized jar (see expert tips below to learn how to sterilize a jar). Make sure you do this before you start making the ketchup.

19. Dissolve ¼ teaspoon of sodium benzoate with 1 teaspoon hot water in a small bowl.

20. Add the sodium benzoate mixture to the hot tomato sauce.

21. Stir and mix very well.

22. Pour the hot tomato sauce in the sterilized jar keeping half to one inch space on top.

Cover tightly and keep it at room temperature till it cools or for a whole day. Then refrigerate it and you can serve the tomato ketchup after 1 or 2 days.

You can serve it with snacks like Samosa, Veg Pizza, kabab, Veg Noodles, Bread Roll, and Veg Burger.

Expert Tips

• Tomatoes: Use fresh ripe, red tomatoes in this recipe to get the best flavor! Avoid bruised and unripened tomatoes. You can also half, double, or triple the number of tomatoes in this recipe depending on how much quantity you want to make.
• Sterilizing jars: To get the best results make sure you sterilize the canning jar before storing the tomato ketchup. Start by rinsing the canning jar. Then boil water in a large saucepan till it reaches its boiling point. Soak the jar and lid in the hot water then continue to boil the water for 8 to 10 minutes.
  Use tongs to remove the canning jar and leave it to drain upside down on a thick towel on a kitchen tabletop. Once the canning jar is completely air-dried the tomato sauce can be stored. Either use canning jars or use heat proof glass jars.
• Preservatives: In order to store this delicious tomato sauce for a long amount of time you will need to add sodium benzoate which is a preservative. The sodium benzoate is added once you have finished preparing the ketchup. To prepare it mix 1 teaspoon of hot water with ¼ teaspoon of sodium benzoate. Allow the sodium benzoate to dissolve then pour it into the hot tomato ketchup and stir.
  If you are not comfortable using preservative then make a small batch of the sauce and store in sterilized glass jars. Or you can follow the canning method of boiling and sterilizing in hot water the sealed canning jars with the sauce inside them.

FAQs

If you’ve tried this recipe, please rate it in the recipe card or leave a comment below – I’d love to hear your feedback. For more vegetarian inspiration, sign up for my email updates or follow me on Instagram, Youtube, Facebook, Pinterest or X.

Tomato Ketchup recipe from the blog archives was first published on January 2014.