Bhaturas are thick leavened fried Indian bread often eaten with chole/channa (spicy curried garbanzo beans/kabuli channa/chick peas)
I wanted to post and share this great Bhatura recipe from a long time and finally, I am able to do it today. I just enjoyed making these bhature for the first time, on my hubby’s birthday. He is a great fan of Chole Bhature and I had decided to make it specially for him on his birthday.
Though, I have cooked chole many times, it was always with pooris. This time I wanted to make bhaturas. I know from examples of my friends that the bhatura is not so easy to make and it does not rise or puff up while frying. This was my first time and I did not want to take a chance.
I checked on the internet and there were many recipes for bhatura – with yeast, without yeast, with eno and so on…… the list is endless. Finally, I decided to adapt this recipe, from a book which has tested and tried recipes from the world of Iskcon – The Hare Krishna Book of Vegetarian Cooking.
When I fried the bhaturas in oil……. I joyfully gleed….. the bhaturas not only puffed up……… they puffed up really well…….. like the way the bhatura actually has to puff up. Also, they were soft from inside and crisp from outside.
My hubby was shocked……… how come I managed such great and awesome bhaturas and that too the first time. He relished it so much that I decided to make it again.
So the second time now, I made chole bhature for my mom-in-law as she too loves it. Again, this bhatura recipe did not fail me this time. The bhature came out great again.
The other good point of this bhatura recipe is that it used less of all purpose flour (maida)/refined white flour and more of whole wheat flour (atta). The ratio of all purpose flour to whole wheat flour used in this recipe is approx 1:3 respectively.
Some of the other bhatura recipes are made of only refined wheat flour. They are tasty but not so good for health. Thats why I chose this recipe. I have one more bhatura recipe which is made using mashed potatoes. This aloo bhatura recipe is also a step by step recipe.
Also, this bhatura recipe is made without yeast. For the leavening of the flour, curd and baking powder/baking soda is used.
The rolling and frying of the bhaturas takes around 20-30 mins. But the leavening of the flour, takes 8 hours (overnight) plus 2 hours. I made the bhaturas with Amritsari Chole.
The old pics have been updated with new pics, since I always end up making bhatura this way to go with chole on festive or special ocassions. I guess I love fermented foods and hence always go for this tried and tested bhatura recipe.
Step by Step method to make the Bhatura:
- You will have to start the night before. In a bowl take the yoghurt, sugar, baking powder and all purpose flour. Mix well all the above 4 ingredients.
- Cover the bowl with a cloth or lid and set it aside in a warm place overnight or for 8 hours to allow natural fermentation to take place. The next day you will see tiny bubbles on the surface of the mixture. I stirred the mixture and so the bubbles cannot be seen in this pic.
- In another bowl, mix together the wheat flour with salt and rub the oil or ghee or butter into it with your fingertips.
- Into this bowl, add the fermented mixture and the warm water.
- Mix everything well.
- Knead into a dough for 5 to 10 minutes or until it is silky smooth. Add a little flour if it is too wet.
- Gather the dough into a compact ball and cover it with a damp cloth. Again set it aside in a warm place for 2 hrs. This is how the dough appears after 2 hours.
- Knead the dough again. Form it in to 12-15 balls.
- Roll each into 4-5 inch discs.
- Heat oil or ghee and deep fry the bhaturas in the same way as you would fry pooris.
- Fry till golden. The bhaturas will take a bit longer to fry than pooris.
- Drain on kitchen paper napkins.
- Continue to fry each bhatura this way.
- Serve the bhaturas hot with chole and wedges of lemon and sliced onions.
Bhatura Recipe details are given below:
- 21/2 cups atta or whole wheat flour
- 1 tsp salt or as required
- 1 tbsp oil or ghee or butter
- ½ or ⅓ cup warm water
- vegetable oil for deep frying
- ¾ cup (150 ml) plain curd/yoghurt or cashew curd
- ½ tbsp sugar or brown sugar
- ½ tsp baking powder
- ¾ cup all purpose flour/maida
- ¼ cup water (optional)
- You will have to start the night before.
- In a bowl take the yoghurt, sugar, baking powder and all purpose flour.
- Mix well all the above 4 ingredients mentioned for overnight fermentation.
- If the yogurt has whey in it, then don’t need to add the ¼ cup water mentioned above.
- If the yogurt is thick, then to thin the batter, add ¼ cup water.
- Cover the bowl with a cloth and set it aside in a warm place overnight or for 8 hours to allow natural fermentation to take place.
- The next day you will see tiny bubbles on the surface of the mixture. The mixture is ready for the next step when tiny bubbles appear on the surface.
- In another bowl, mix together the wheat flour with salt and rub the ghee or butter into it with your fingertips. Into this bowl, add the fermenting mixture and the warm water. Form a dough with these two mixtures.
- Knead the dough for 5 to 10 minutes or until it is silky smooth. Add a little flour if it is too wet. Gather the dough into a compact ball and cover it with a damp cloth. Again set it aside in a warm place for 2 hrs.
- This is how the dough appears after 2 hours.
- Knead the dough again.
- Form it in to 15 balls and roll them into 5-6 inch discs. Heat oil or ghee and deep fry the bhaturas in the same way as you would fry pooris. Serve the bhaturas hot with chole and wedges of lemon and sliced onions.
{ 100 comments… read them below or add one }
mine bhatura become very thick ,many didn’t puff up .it used to break while frying.pls give some tip
frying bhatura is exactly like frying puri. something must have gone wrong in the kneading process or in the water – flour ratio. hence the bahturas did not puff up.
pls let me know which oil did u use? refind or musturd?
thanks
shreya
i have used rice bran oil. you can also use sunflower or safflower oil. avoid using mustard oil.
thank u very much for the awesome recipe.
thnx we found ur recipie very convinient
hey.. i just love to cook….
but i was litle confused how to make dough for bhautras..
through this i can make the dough very easily… thankU sho much..
thanks.
what is the meaning of rolling into 5-6 inch disc? can i do that with the use of polpat-latne?
hi purva, rolling means the way we roll chapatis or rotis with the rolling pin which is called belan in hindi or latne in marathi. you have to use the polpat-latne for rolling the bhatura.
I believe that there is no need of adding baking soda. As, we are already adding curd which is more then enough. If we are not putting the dough for a long time then we can add the baking soda. A sin this case as we are already keeping the dough for around 8hrs, its not required. Baking soda changes the taste of the food. So avoid using it if you enough preparation time.
hi amit, since this recipe is adapted from a book, i kept the ingredients as it is and it works for me when i make these bhaturas. the idea of adding baking powder or soda is that it helps in leavening of the flour and makes the dough light and fluffy. baking soda does have a soapy taste, so baking powder can be added instead.
i really like ur receipes i will try ur more receipes thank u so much
Aapki recipe ka tarika bot acha hota ha ma hameha follwo karti hu bhatura recipe bhi try ki thi very nice god bless you thanks.
thanks mina
hello, i tried and it came out very well. thanks a ton for posting this recipe. useful work ever.
thanks
Hi Dassana,
I have a small doubt, my understanding is mixing of wheat flour and sugar has to be done in morning NOT in the night when “white flour and yoghurt” mixing is done.
the sugar, white flour, yogurt and baking powder have to be mixed in the night. this mixture is allowed to ferment for 8 hours. then this mixture is added to the whole wheat flour and oil mixture.
i live in australia and dont know how to make all that stuff please suggest some simple ideas thanx =D
Use 2 teaspoon of yeast with half teaspoon of sugar and 3/4 cup of lukewarm water for 15 minutes and then mix that to the dough, if you do not have yogurt and time to ferment the dough !
thanks for this tip.
Perfect recipe…made it and enjoyed it too…Thank you for exploring and posting the recipe Dassana
thank u ……….
now i can eat batura at home with happily…………………….
yummy and tasty
i surfed a lot for the recipe.. Stumbled upon many.. And this one.. It was perfect.. Tried it and fell in love with it.. Crispy n soft too.. Tnx a lot!
hey zahira. thanks
I agree with suhani the yogurt measurement seems to be off maybe because it is store bought yogurt as is yogurt in US is more thicker than India I am making it now will definitely update the results later
dear shirin, the yogurt measurement is what i have used as mentioned in the cookbook from where i have adapted the recipe…sure do update me.
hi Dassana i made bhaturas again few days back and this time they turned out very nice and tasty..i paired them up with pindi chole..and we had a wholesome dinner..again thanks for ur guidance..
thanks suhani… long time i have not made chole nor bhaturas at home…. plan to make these bhaturas soon.
Hi im setayesh a female from iran.i visited your website and enjoyed.i decieded to translate your recipes by keeping your name if you please.
dear setayesh, it is alright. as long as you give the link to the original content on my blog, i am alright with it.
thanks dassana.
I tried your recipe after googling many others… your awesome pics and use of whole wheat atta encouraged me to try it.. And it was fantastic.. Loved every bit of it and also the texture was fabulous, thaaaaaaanx a lot
thanks shilpa. comments like yours encourage and motivate me to share more recipes.
I tried the recipe n it turned out to be the awesome.Thanks.
welcome rama
Hi
I’m not sure if the white flour & wheat flour ratios is accurate!
At one place the author said the ratio is 0.6:3, but under ingredients she said 150 gms and 300 gms, which one of these is right?
John
the quantity of flours mentioned in the ingredients is right. the author forgot to update the the ratio part in the post.
yes now i understood why my bhaturas were not good anyways i will add more yogurt to the mixture next time..thanks Dassana
hey dassana..this bhatura recipe is the original recipe with a natural fermentation..i liked it very much however the results were not good for me..firstly when i made the white flour mixture it was not a paste consistency as it can be seen in ur pics..it was a dough like consistency anyhow i added warm milk to it for giving it the correct paste form..the next day i made the dough with wheat flour as per ur recipe..now when i was deep frying they didnt easily puffed up like urs..where did i go wrong..may be u can help me out.. i dont want it to happen next time..plz help me
i think the addition of milk has made affected the leavening process. i am unsure why you did not get a paste like consistency. instead of adding milk, you could have just added some more yogurt. that would have helped the bhaturas to ferment well.
Hi Dassana!
I lived in India for 6 years and back home(Iran) for 4 . I madly miss this dish and I ave many memories with this delicous food. I really appreciate your taste, design and the fact that you are so meticilous, sharing the pics very beautifully. I guess you must be working in some food magazine or something. You must be the Lady at home. Thaks fo the recipe. I’m gonna try it. we can also keep in touch! Hindustan ko bhot miss kia hai
thanks sepideh for the lovely comments. you can subscribe to my mailing list and get indian as well other recipes. link is http://forms.aweber.com/form/64/1800486464.htm
i have never worked in any food magazine. but you are right… i am the lady at my home
Thank you so much!
Turned out marvellous. Tks to you again…….
Btw do you have recipes for arabic dishes like zattar and cheese fatayar
Tks
thanks deepa. the bhatura is a tried and tested recipe and has always worked for me.
i do not have arabic dishes like zattar and cheese fatayar. i know of zattar but cheese fatayar i will have to find out.
Tks for your response. Does not matter… Actually , I am at present in Doha, State of Qatar and will be moving back to India by end of next month. We are so very used to the arabic dishes for the past 15 years and will miss them back home. Hence was enquiring eagerly. Tks for all your guidance.
you may get the arabic spice blends and other edibles if you stay in the metro cities. but if you are going to stay in the towns or villages of india, then you might end up making them at home like me
Hi Dassana
Have made the dough today. Just waiting to see the results..will let u know soon. Recipe looks yummy !
awesem,,,any easy way of telling recipe,,,,,thnxxxxxxxxxxxxx
thanks monika.
Tried this recipe and it was a grand success. Thanks for the recipe.
thats nice to know suja…
i m planning to make bhature bt i m little cnfsed cz my experience was so bad wen i made dz last tme
dear ritu, this one is a tried and tested recipe. if you are not sure about this one then there is another one on this link which you can try making at home. its easy and simple to make. bhatura made with mashed potatoes – aloo bhatura
http://www.vegrecipesofindia.com/aloo-bhatura/
oh dassana you are simply superb sweetheart, the bathuras looks simply delicious, i never knew that this need to be fermented a night before, thankx once again.
thanks neela. do try this bhatura recipe. its too good.
Came out really well. Thank you for the detailed description.
thanks preetha. nice to know that the bhaturas were good.
Please inform if Bhatura came out dry and not oily
dear poornima, the oil should be moderately hot for frying the bhaturas. if it is warm then the bhaturas will soak up the oil and become oily.
hi,this recipe is awesome
can u tell me what other thing serve with this?
i m little confuse.can i serve with any chatny?
i have tasted it at our relative home….
that was so yummy,it was tasted with immlys -red dark chatny..
can u solve my confusion?
hetal, generally bhatura is served with chole/chana…. however you can serve it with a potato sabzi along with some chopped onions, lime and the sweet imli chutney & green mint coriander chutney…. it will be a great combination. but just don’t serve the bhaturas with chutney…. have something substantial to go with the chutney…..
This way of preparation looks amazing.Tomorow I am going to prepare in this way.Tomorow is a occasin of son’s birthday.I am going to celebrate with Chole & this bhature.
thats great vjay. do let me know how the bhature turned out.
Dear frnd..
I am going to prepare Bhatura…thank you for the recipe
Asha
hey asha, do let me know how they turned out.
Success!! Thank you Dassana for this wonderful recipe:-)
welcome asha…..
Hey Dassana, i was just making the Bhature and i guess that the white flour measurement in grams is incorrect… 2/3 cup of white flour is 80 gm not 150 gm. I checked it on http://www.jsward.com/cooking/conversion.shtml as after mixing the 4 ingredients its consistency is already like a chapati dough
dear archana
thanks for pointing this.
i went through the cookbook from where i have taken this recipe and the ingredients measurements are the same as on the blog. for all the recipes in the book, they have given american measurements. i did a bit of research on the web, but found all conflicting results. so i am not sure what is what.
i think its a typo error on their part. i have now changed it to 1½ cup.
whenever i have made this recipe, i have used the gram measurement. i have always used 150 gms of white flour. i am not sure how the bhaturas turned out at your end, but i do hope they were good.
these recipies are just amazing …..the best thing is that u can see the pis of the dishes too……great
Have eaten bhaturas outside but never prepared by self. But your demonstration makes me eager to prepare it at home. m going to prepare it tomorrow… n yes m dead sure ( in advance) that its gonna taste fabulous. THANK YOU.
thanks bandhana
Hey.. Thanks a lot for the recipe and its narration. I will surely try this today..
Well, There is another way of making bhatura, instantly and just like road side vendors in India. Bhatura will be very thin and and instant.
Just take proper measurement of Maida (floor), Paneer (200 grams for 1/2 Kg maida), 100 gram dahi or yougart or curd, pinch of salt, and make the dough with club soda. keep it aside for 1 hr before you use.
Check it out and it will be just like indian road side bhatura.
You can also wash rings of raw onions with remaining club soda and it will take the onions smells off (atleast 50%, it not 100%)
thanks sanj for this quick recipe of bhatura. it will help all the readers.
thanks also for the tip on getting rid of the smell of sliced raw onions.
ek number banaya hai
I am a Bhatura fan! I have tried many variety of bhaturas, but this is really amazing and so nice. The recipie and narration are so outstanding. Thank you very much.
wonderful
thanks for you seema ji
Delicious & Mouth-watering!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*
thanksssss for ur g8 help…now i can keep everyone happy
its really nice to have such a easy and good receipe for making bhaturas. I used to think how to find way to make bhatura and also keeping in mind the health point. My whole family is fond of chole bhature.
Thanks for sharing this recipe with every one. I will surely try the same way
thanks shweta….. do try the bhatura recipe….
what is thatwhite flour?
white flour or refined wheat flour is maida in hindi…. the flour which is commonly used for making breads and cakes.
The bhatura recipe shown above is awesome. I tried and i try to show all my relastives and friends to make the bahtura’s the same way. Thanks for this one…it really worked for me.
thanks sonia….. this one is a tried and tested bhatura recipe for me and always worked for me. i am sure your friends and relatives will also have a nice time making the bhatura…
Seems a completely different way of making bhaturas. Will try this wk end.
do try this bhatura recipe…. its very good….
Awesome and yummy dish!!!!
thanx for this recipe. …….
liked ur recipe from health point of view n would surely like to try it.I would like to know whether the final prepared dough can be kept in the refrigerator nad used later or not say a day or two after it was prepared?
i think you could use it on the next day after keeping in the refrigerator. i have never tried though doing this. better to use it in a day rather than using in after two or three days.
Awesome recipe with great focus to details.
the demonstartion is amazing and makes u really want to try it. For not so great cook like me, I do really need something like this to encourage me try it. thank u.
awesome and yummy recipe my fav dish